Custom Search Shelter Island, New York Ghost Sightings Ghost photos from Shelter Island Shelter Island PAGE 1   2     Daytime in Shelter Island, New York is exactly identical to daytime anywhere else in the US of A, but there are extraordinary things happening in this city in the dark hours. Some of the passed away won't stay in their graves in this town. Not everyone believes in the accounts the folks who live here tell, but scary things certainly occur here in Shelter Island during the moonlight hours. These are some of the spooky     things that have happened in nearby cities and towns. Southampton 10 miles away: The ghost of a little girl can be seen peeking out a windmill window, where she had died by falling down the stairs and breaking her neck as a child at a college in Southampton....   (continued on the next page...) More Shelter Island Area Ghost Sightings On The Next Page >> Submit a ghost sighting for Shelter Island, New York: Your Name: Write or Paste Input here: Upload picture:       Other haunted towns near Shelter Island, New York: Shelter Island Heights, New York, 1 miles away Greenport, New York, 3 miles away East Marion, New York, 3 miles away Sag Harbor, New York, 5 miles away Bridgehampton, New York, 6 miles away Southold, New York, 6 miles away Sagaponack, New York, 7 miles away Water Mill, New York, 7 miles away Orient, New York, 8 miles away Peconic, New York, 8 miles away Wainscott, New York, 8 miles away        The latest ghost sightings from around the world All haunted towns and cities in New York Psychic Predictions Lies about Shelter Island