Shelter Island, New York Ghost Tales During the daylight hours you might think Shelter Island, New York is exactly the same as any other municipality, but there are ghosts in this municipality, and they show up in the dark hours. The spirits of this city don’t leave anyone unfrightened. People who have never spent the night in this city will inform you it's all just superstition, but the things that go down here in Shelter Island in the night time will scare you. These are some of the spooky things that have happened here recently. The phantom of an old Indian chief was distinguished being carried       by a bicycle on a shady road outside Shelter Island. When the spirit was witnessed it faded away into the air. A man who lives here says that this ghost is that of a resident who lived here in Shelter   Island before the present. In any case, it's undoubtedly a terrifying spirit that you shouldn't go searching for. A pitch black snake that shape-shifted into a woman emerged on a dark night crawling out of Gardiners Creek soaked in mud. Alarmed by the bystanders the phantom receded into the darkness. No matter what, this ghost undoubtedly is frightening; one that should be steered clear of. The ghost of a young female dressed as a maid emerged soaring across the South Ferry Hills in the early morning hours before sunrise. When perceived the phantom came within reach of the observer who then ran away. One of the locals confidently asserts that this phantom likes startling people who are brave enough to interrupt the serenity in Shelter Island. The ghost of a youthful cowboy was perceived taking a midnight bath at Crescent Beach. There have been further descriptions on the subject of this spirit in the area. A number of folks say this ghost enjoys terrifying unwise folks who come looking for ghosts in Shelter Island. A menacing being was perceived in a flat in Shelter Island. Several stories of this ghost have been conveyed. It's been alleged that this particular ghost could be the spirit of a local person who passed away here in Shelter Island some time ago. Submit a ghost sighting for Shelter Island, New York: Your Name: Write or Paste Input here: Upload picture:       Other haunted towns near Shelter Island, New York: Shelter Island Heights, New York, 1 miles away Greenport, New York, 3 miles away East Marion, New York, 3 miles away Sag Harbor, New York, 5 miles away Bridgehampton, New York, 6 miles away Southold, New York, 6 miles away Sagaponack, New York, 7 miles away Water Mill, New York, 7 miles away Orient, New York, 8 miles away Peconic, New York, 8 miles away Wainscott, New York, 8 miles away        The latest ghost sightings from around the whole US All haunted towns and cities in New York