Water Mill, New York Ghost Tales There's not a single thing outlandish involving Water Mill, New York in the daylight hours, but this area has a quite good percentage of ghosts. The undeceased are all over this municipality as the folks who live here will inform you. Skeptics don't trust in the local phantom stories, but the things that go down here in Water Mill at night will give you a good scare. These are some of the spooky things that have happened here recently. A woman with her left arm and right leg cut off can be seen very often in Mud Creek late at night struggling to dump a cadaver. The ghost of a gentleman clutching a blood-covered sword has from time to time been witnessed pulling a cadaver from the ice cold water of Calf Creek in the early morning hours. The spirit of a civil war combatant is known to have been distinguished on a small number of occasions climbing out of a drain hole on a Water Mill residential street around midnight. The ghost of a guy having a pentagram etched into his arm can every       so often be distinguished poking around in mailboxes on a dark night in Water Mill. The ghost of a badly mangled huntsman hauling a dead moose has repeatedly been made out attempting to grip something in Agawam Park on a dark night.   Submit a ghost sighting for Water Mill, New York: Your Name: Write or Paste Input here: Upload picture:       Other haunted towns near Water Mill, New York: Sag Harbor, New York, 3 miles away Bridgehampton, New York, 4 miles away Southampton, New York, 4 miles away Sagaponack, New York, 5 miles away Shelter Island, New York, 7 miles away Shelter Island Heights, New York, 7 miles away Wainscott, New York, 7 miles away Southold, New York, 8 miles away Greenport, New York, 9 miles away New Suffolk, New York, 9 miles away Peconic, New York, 9 miles away        The latest ghost sightings from around the world All haunted towns and cities in New York